Do you feel dread when you hear the words “budget” or ‘”budget process?” Based on my discussions with pastors and parish administrators over the years, you are absolutely not alone! No need to fret! Break the process down into four manageable stages and watch as you reap the benefits of creating a collaborative, transparent, and efficient budget.
Stage 1 – Establish Priorities
If the budget is a reflection of priorities, it’s important in the first stage to establish priorities. Stage 1 includes the examination of Church mission, vision, goals, and objectives. This is the stage when pastoral leaders collaborate with staff, parishioners, or other stakeholders and encourage an open dialogue about where the parishes today and what the parish hopes to accomplish in the future. As previously discussed on this blog, the budget is a reflection of your priorities. Therefore, it’s critical to spend some time thinking and praying over what you want to accomplish. Otherwise, the budget may become a shelf document and not a management tool to help you accomplish your goals and objectives.
Timing: 4-5 months prior to the budget being finalized
Stage 2 – Deliver Guidance
In Stage 2, create a roadmap to help you and your team arrive at your destination. This is the stage to discuss targets and expectations. Most income and expense estimates contain uncertainty anyway, so take the worry out of the creation of the budget.
It can be as simple as developing a brief one or two-page document that offers guidance, expectations, and timelines to those helping you create the budget.
This is also the stage to address any assumptions that will impact budget creation. For example, if you have a budget target in mind for a program or initiative, let people know. Don’t keep them guessing as to what you are thinking. People want direct feedback. No one wants to create a budget proposal only to find out that the program was not even considered!
Otherwise, the budget formulation process becomes a “paper exercise” that undermines your leadership and dissatisfies those working with you. Expectation setting may be challenging to deliver in the moment, but being honest with people saves everyone in the end. Transparency around decision-making also helps you gain the trust and respect of your colleagues. Allow adequate time for estimates and justifications to be produced.
Timing: 3-4 months prior to the budget being finalized
Stage 3 – Develop Budget
Stage 3 is when your team estimates parish income and expenses, design program budgets, and create performance goals. Using your parish financial software and other tools at your disposal, you will be able to consolidate information so you can review the various budget elements (income, expenses, and program justifications) from different perspectives. Utilize helpful tools like Microsoft Excel, Google Sheets, or other software programs that serve to consolidate information. When the information is contained in this type of format, you will have a broader perspective and visibility on the various components that will make up your budget.
Timing: 2 months prior to the budget being finalized
Stage 4 – Gain Feedback and Finalize
Share the budget with those you have involved from the earliest phases of the process. After you have a draft budget include stakeholders by allowing them to give you feedback as you prepare your final proposal. This consistent information sharing will continue to build momentum and ultimate buy-in for the creation of a collaborative budget. Buy-in at this stage is defined as ownership and understanding of your budget among stakeholders who are critical for the achievement of your policies and programs. For a parish, this would include staff, parishioners, finance and pastoral councils, and others who help you achieve success.
Timing: 1 month prior to the budget being finalized
Stay Tuned: Tomorrow, we will discuss best practices for implementing these stages.
Read More Church Finance 30/30 – 30 Tips in 30 Days
Portions of this text come from Michael J. Castrilli and Charles E. Zech, Parish Finance: Best Practices in Church Management (New York: Paulist Press, 2016) Chapter 3.